Why offer dual degrees?
A Call for Change | A Response to
Change | The University of Florida Program
A Call for Change in Graduate Education
Although the system of graduate education in the United States is one of
the best in the world for training scientists and engineers, it has
lately come under attack for its inflexibility and for turning out a
steady stream, if not flood, of academic researchers during a time when
government support of research is dwindling and the demand for new
researcher is dropping.
The attack is from three sides. Young scientists are increasingly
critical of the system as they become mired in the mud of perpetual
postdoctoral fellowships or (as 50% of them do) seek employment in a
non-academic or even non-science field. The government has criticized
the system as inflexible, and unwilling or unable to prepare scientists
to contribute to our present natial needs. Industry, which absorbs much
of the overflow of academic researchers, complains that new Ph.D.'s are
often too specialized for the range of task that will confront them in a
non-academic environment.
Because of these real or perceived insufficiences in the way we now train
future scientists, the Committee on Science, Engineering, and Public
Policy of the National Academy of Sciences (NAS) recently published a
lengthy report on "Reshaping the Graduate Education of Scientists and
Engineers." They offertwo broad recommendations to those institutions
involved in the training of scientists and engineers, the essence of
which is to educate our students much more broadly and prepare them for
careers ouside of, as well as inside, academia. They say, "1)To
produce more versatile scientists and engineers, graduate programs should
provide options that allow students to gain a wider variety of skills; and
2) Graduate scientists and engineers and their advisers should receive
more up-to-date and accurate information to help them make informed
decisions about professional careers."
They also recommend that more students be offered the option of a
Masters's degree or a new type of Ph.D. degree in preparation for work in
a non-traditional field. They indicated that Master's degrees have been
typically undervalued, underpromoted, and underused. Both the Master's
degree and the novel Ph.D. would be based on research that required less
time than wourd a thesis or dissertation in preparation for a an academic
career. Presumably, the novel Ph.D. degree would also contain some
non-traditional courses.
Response to Call for Change
The nation's institutions of higher education have responded to the NAS
report in a variety of ways. A number of schools have developed programs
that would more specifically train scientists for the newer
biotechnological industries. Several schools have specifically developed
new Master's degree programs as a result of the NAS report. Northwestern
University has developed a Master's degree program in Biotechnology to
equip students for work in major pharmaceutical firms such as
Northwestern's neighbor, Abbott Labs. Course work in scientific
techniques, research and "corporate survival skills" such as teamwork,
budgets, and federal regulations are all required. Penn State offers a
BS/MBA program with a similar goal. Their program familiarizes students
with some science basics and also awards them an MBA. The University of
Maryland in Baltimore County offers an MS in Applied Molecular Biology
that is also designed to prepare graduates to work in the biotechnology
industry, but primarily as technical support personnel. Their program
requires intensive laboratory work and no business exposure. Cornell
University has developed an MBA for scientists who already have advanced
degrees but who wish, for reasons of need or desire, to work in
management. In this program the MBA is obtained in one year. The
University of Rochester offers a two year MS/MBA program in which
students earn both an MBA and an MS in Microbiology and Immunology.
The University of Florida Program
The University of Florida has also responded to the call for change. In
1995, the College of Medicine began accepting MS students in the
Department of Molecular Genetics and Microbiology. Prior to this, only
students declaring interest in a Ph.D. were accepted into the College.
In 1997, this program became college-wide and interdisciplinary. Under
this program the MS given is in Medical Sciences. Specialties are no
longer designated on the MS degree. With cognizance of a growing number
of businesses engaged in the sophisticated biotechnological sciences, and
desiring to give students a full scientific research experience along
with a complete training in business skills, the University of Florida
also offers a joint MS/MBA. Sponsored by the Florida MBA Program, the
Department of Molecular Genetics and Microbiology, and the Biotechnology
Program, the joint program culminates in two standard degrees, an MS and
an MBA, in three years. Both the MS and MS/MBA require laboratory
research and the writing of a thesis. The goal of both the MS and MS/MBA
programs is to train bright and enthusiastic students who want to work at
the interface of science and business in either research or management of
companies involved in the production and promotion of modern biological
products for use in the solution of global human problems.
In 1999, a new four-year MS/JD program was approved for individuals interested in patent law or other legal aspects of the biotechnology industry. In 2000, a new two-year MSM program has been introduced to train masters students in various disciplines (not just MS students) MBA business courses outside the traditional MBA program to better prepare them for careers involving business. This program is not limited to those with 2+ years work experience and offers many of the same courses and instructors as MBA students.
In 1997, the first full year of recruitment, 6 students have been
accepted into the MS/MBA program and 10 into the MS program. The average
GRE score for the MS/MBA students is 1150, with an average GPA of 3.2.
Most have majored in some field of biology although one environmental
engineering student has been accepted. Most, but not all, have had some
laboratory research experience. The average GRE score for the MS students
is 1110, with an average GPA of 3.3, with most having a biological
sciences background.
If you are interested in other graduate and/or research opportunities, go to
The Office of Research and Graduate Programs
Contact Joyce Conners for more information:
Department of Molecular Genetics and Microbiology
Box 100266, Health Center, Gainesville, FL 32610