Immunology/Microbiology Journal Club

Thanks for participating in providing feedback to your classmates on their journal club presentations.  Please be honest and constructive.  As usual, this form is anonymous.

Presenter:
Ratings:    1 = excellent     2 = very good     3 = fair      4 = needs improvement
Presentation Style:

Volume of voice:    1     2     3     4
Speech - speed/clarity:    1     2     3     4
Eye contact with audience: 1     2     3     4
Use of pointer: 1     2     3     4
Gestures: 1     2     3     4
Audiovisual aids: 1     2     3     4
Location relative to screen: 1     2     3     4

Any other comments about presentation style:

Content:

Amount of material covered: 1     2     3     4

Length of talk: 1     2     3     4

Organization of the material presented: 1     2     3     4

Clarity in explaining key points: 1     2     3     4

Logical flow of material: 1     2     3     4

Sufficient background presented: 1     2     3     4

Adequacy of reference material: 1     2     3     4

Adequacy of conclusions/acknowledgments: 1     2     3     4

Any other comments about content:

Overall rating: 1     2     3     4
1 = comparable to the best journal club I’ve ever seen
2 = very good, among the best I’ve ever seen
3 = comparable to the average presentation I’ve ever seen
4 = needs improvement